• Skip to main content
  • Skip to footer

Easly

Innovative Financing for Innovators

  • Easly Advances
    • How it Works
    • SR&ED Financing
    • Our Customers
  • About
    • Company
    • Careers
    • Contact
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • News & Events
    • Easly Calculator
    • SR&ED Calculator
    • FAQ
  • Easly Calculator
  • Apply Now
  • CAN
    • UK
Back to Blog
Share on Linkedin Twitter Facebook

Don’t Let Unfavourable Debt Financing Terms Sink Your Startup: A Lawyer’s Guide from Gilbert’s LLP

15 Feb 2023

Don’t Let Unfavourable Debt Financing Terms Sink Your Startup: A Lawyer’s Guide from Gilbert’s LLP
Published on: February 15, 2023

Debt financing can be a great capital-raising vehicle for growing companies. It can stave off valuation issues and prevent the need for early dilution. However, startups often have difficulty securing debt as lenders are wary of extending credit to companies without lengthy credit histories. Furthermore, some loan agreements offered to startups can include terms that threaten the financial future of a company or its principals.

When seeking debt financing, two considerations startups should watch for (and sometimes walk away from) are:

a) personal guarantees

b) broad security interests

Personal Guarantees

Lenders often seek personal guarantees from early-stage companies because they lack sufficient credit history and assets to be considered creditworthy. These kinds of assurances can put individual guarantors (often the company founders) at significant risk as they can become personally responsible for the debts of the company. 

Sometimes individuals attempt to “credit-proof” themselves or reduce the consequences of personal bankruptcy by protecting assets from potential seizure by creditors. That can be a risky and challenging strategy. On occasion, courts have even rolled back actions that guarantors have taken to credit-proof their assets (e.g. by voiding a contract).

For example, in Bank of Montreal v Javed (2016 ONCA 49), the Ontario Court of Appeal considered a Bank of Montreal small business loan made to a donut shop in 2011. The loan was provided based on personal guarantees, which the court enforced. One of the guarantors had not had an active role in the business for several years when the company finally defaulted. Moreover, the court found that the guarantor’s attempt to transfer their interest in their matrimonial home to their spouse was a fraudulent conveyance. Despite attempts to provide a reason for the transfer that was unrelated to the knowledge of the corporation’s financial problems, the court undid the transfer.

Attempting to shield assets after providing a personal guarantee is a risk that borrowers should be aware of, especially with respect to personal assets that could potentially be seized.

Secured Loans & Broad Security Interests

In addition to personal guarantees, lenders may also seek security for the loan. A loan may be secured against specific assets, such as inventory, or against all of the company’s property. Such security can mean that, in the case of an unresolved default, a lender can eventually enforce its rights by seizing and selling those assets, sometimes at a loss, in order to be made whole.

A secured loan will often have a lower rate of interest than an unsecured loan since it is backed by some asset(s). However, it is crucial for borrowers to consider which asset(s) to choose as loan collateral, as secured lenders will have priority rights over other lenders to that business asset(s). For example, providing a secured interest against a company’s accrued refundable SR&ED tax credits may be a better option than providing a secured interest against a company’s inventory. If the latter is seized, it could immediately affect the company’s ability to generate income.

While such a devastating result may seem unfair, unfortunately, such outcomes are often upheld. Absent misrepresentations and fraud, courts can have little sympathy for a party making a bad bargain. As the Ontario Court of Appeal said in the case of Titus v. William F. Cooke Enterprises Inc. (2007 ONCA 573), “[a] transaction may, in the eyes of one party, turn out to be foolhardy, burdensome, undesirable or improvident…” and yet remain enforceable.

Access Debt Financing Confidently

Prior to taking on any form of debt financing, companies and individuals should make sure they are able to meet their obligations and understand the potential liability if they fail to do so. In an ideal world, your business should only seek loans secured against assets that, if seized and sold, do not pose an existential threat to the company. This is where tax credit financing can play a vital role.

In general, loans secured against refundable tax credits are given when the lender is confident that the estimated refund is accurate. With a proper accounting of qualified expenditure, both the lender and debtor can be confident that the tax credit refund used to secure against the loan will be disbursed by the CRA, which in turn pays back all principal and fees to the lender. This allows the debtor to benefit from the lower cost of a secured loan without having to secure against an asset crucial to operations, such as inventory.

If your company has questions about different types of debt financing and how they can affect your business, get in touch with legal experts on the Slingshot team at Gilbert’s LLP.

 

Written by,

Paul Banwatt, Partner, Gilbert's LLP Paul Banwatt

Partner, Gilbert’s LLP

Ridhey Gill, Student-At-Law, Gilbert's LLP Ridhey Gill

IPC Student, Gilbert’s LLP

Debt financingPersonal Guaranteestax credit financing
Contact Us
Share on Linkedin Twitter Facebook
Prev Post
Next Post
Business FinancingWhy Debt Financing is an Attractive Option for Startups and Scale-UpsWhy Debt Financing is Attractive for Startups & Scale-ups - Image of an individual stacking blocks with dollar signs on them.
FinancingWhat is Non-Dilutive Funding (Financing)?A group of people working together
FinancingAll About Cash Flow – Startups Should Avoid These PitfallsA space full of people in the foreground with focus on a whiteboard that says Startupday

Footer CTA

Easly White Logo
  • Home
  • Easly Advances
    • How It Works
    • SR&ED Financing
    • Our Customers
  • About
    • Company
    • Careers
    • Contact
  • Resources
    • Blog
    • News & Events
    • Easly Calculator
    • SR&ED Calculator
    • FAQ
  • Apply Now

© ESFC Funding Co., LLC 2025
Privacy Policy Terms of Use
Linkedin

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and are used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory for us to procure your consent prior to running these cookies on our website.
SAVE & ACCEPT